My first crush that I can remember is a boy I went to school with in the first grade. He had bright red hair and freckles. I liked him for quite a while based only on his cute frecklieness, as we really had nothing in common. I met my very first boyfriend years later at 14 in another school, and he too had red hair and freckles. It was just a thing I went for when I was younger. My celebrity crushes were a whole different thing. I'm not even sure I can call these guys crushes since I was only a kid, but I remember blushing when they were on TV.
Christopher Reeve as Superman
Lou Ferrigno as the Incredible Hulk
Disney's Peter Pan
Okay so I had a thing for made up characters. Who doesn't!?